Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - SkyhunterCommander

Pages: 1 [2] 3 4
16
As I said in the email, sorry for getting this out so late. This chapter introduces a new viewpoint- minor compared to the other two I've done so far-he will only have 2-3 chapters to himself, in addition to a few sections in chapters with multiple viewpoints.

This chapter was a bit hard for me to write-Dalcon's viewpoint did not come to me as easily as Darkclaw's and Nayasar's. Also, the first draft of this chapter was way too infodumpy, which is why I took an extra week to rewrite it. I think I fixed most of it, but if anything comes off as an infodump, don't hesitate to mention it.

And and all feedback/comments are greatly appreciated!


Brief Summary: Second Scion Dalcon the Bright joins a mission to find out why all contact was lost from an information storage station three weeks ago. What he finds troubles him.

Summaries of previous chapters:

Chapter 2: Introduces Grand Admiral Nayasar, the young supreme commander of the Felinaris military, who is also their heir to the throne. She waits with her subordinate and close friend Admiral Felivas for a formal meeting with her father, in which she will propose a plan to exact revenge on those responsible for an attack on the Felinaris homeworld that killed many. When her plan is not accepted, she storms out and Felivas tries to calm her down.

Chapter 3: The Troodons, before building their army, are ordered to raid an information station-essentially a giant library- on the edge of Galactic Alliance space to learn what they can about their eventual enemy. Darkclaw sends his subordinate Praetor Keeneye to lead the mission, and watches through a helmet feed. The station is captured without incident, and Darkclaw completes his mission. He relates this to the High Lord, who instructs him to set a course for a hidden station where they will build an army.

Chapter 4: Nayasar is overworking herself, and Felivas demands that she take a mental health day.

Chapter 5: Darkclaw and the Troodons arrive at Selixan Station, a station left by the Saviors, created to rapidly build an army for the Troodons.

17
Reading Excuses / Re: Email List + Submission Dates
« on: July 04, 2011, 05:44:11 AM »
I plan to submit a chapter today. (After getting some sleep that is.)

18
Thanks for the tip regarding adverbs. It's not something I do intentionally, but I'll try to watch out for them, and try to cut down on that.

And as far as the describing and explaining goes, I'm aware that I have a slight tendency to want to tell everything (just part of being an outliner) but I've been actively working on limiting it to what is needed. That's why I probably won't have a chapter for this week; I'm rewriting chapter 6 because the first draft had way too much exposition.

The funny thing about the name Troodon is that it's actually the name of a real dinosaur that lived in the late Cretaceous-I've always been somewhat open to changing it because I was worried that people wouldn't like the direct tie to a real creature, so I found your issue with it amusing-the same general issue, but an entirely different reason. And as for the High Lord, I'm open to change as well if needed-I'm sticking with it for now because that's what I originally called him when I conceptualized him and the story, but it's not something I'll fight to the death for, unlike some of my other name choices.

I can answer any questions about the High Lord's level of power, but at this point I'd rather let you figure out what's up with him through the story. But it's great that there's already a theory 5 chapters in. :)

As for human POV's, I don't plan on including any at this point-I have already introduced my two main POV's, and I will have two or three minor ones, as the story requires it (two would be the POV of previously introduced characters, the third is the POV in chapter 6-another reason why it's taking longer). If at some point I find it necessary and it fits with the story, I am not necessarily opposed to a human POV though. My only thing is for the main characters to not be human.

19
Reading Excuses / Re: Email List + Submission Dates
« on: June 26, 2011, 09:03:28 PM »
I might have a chapter ready for tomorrow, depending on how writing goes today.

20
Thanks for the feedback, I'm glad that everyone seems to like the banter between Nayasar and Felivas.

As far as the issue about learning something new, that's really not something I've thought about much. As you mentioned, the primary purpose of the chapter is to provide a break between the early Darkclaw chapters (as of the first Darkclaw chapter after chapter 5, I don't anticipate needing to do that any more, and will probably swift viewpoints when it suits the plot as opposed to alternating every chapter).

As I was writing it I was aiming to mostly just build on their characters and situation, as introduced in chapter 2, as well as have a somewhat lighthearted series of events before everything gets more serious. I see what you mean about it not really having much that is new, but at least as of now I don't see it as a problem (though that opinion can change somewhere down the line). Bear in mind that this is very early in the story, and as such I would hope that the reader would find them (as well as the other events) interesting enough to continue to read through despite nothing 'new' in this chapter.

That being said, I could perhaps start the scene earlier (as opposed to when Felivas walks in), and spend a little time delving into Nayasar's head a bit, to show how she is not only focused, but obsessed at this point. (The fact that she's obsessed with this and haunted by what happened is something that was going to come up, but I just didn't think of introducing it here. Do you think that sort of new information might resolve this issue?

21
I appreciate the feedback, even if you haven't read the earlier chapters. If you'd like, I can email you the others.

Thanks for catching the minutes thing. With some of the other characters, who live within an interplanetary community, there is a standard time that might not be the same as the length of time on that world. There, where there might be a difference between the standard time units and planetary time units, it makes sense. But looking back, the Troodons, who only have their own sense of time, he should not use that term.

Those two paragraphs reference conflicts that relate to my other main character that was described by her earlier, and this is building toward an event later in the story.

The throne room was described in detail previously, and I didn't want to be redundant and describe the same thing again.

Darkclaw is aware when the High Lord is reading his mind, so when he has information that the High Lord would want to know, he will go inform him. Also, as a show of respect, he informs him of things and reports to him personally. And yes, the High Lord does explain things a lot, but it's primarily because he alone, as supreme leader, knows what their next move is, among other things. The High Lord is the kind of person (sort of) that likes telling his underlings things, and can go on for a while.

Taking the call is not quite the same thing, since as you said, Darkclaw knows what the call will be about, which is directly related to the High Lord's commands. Though I could change it a bit, make the High Lord know that they have arrived before Darkclaw can answer the call if you think that would work better.

I think I meant to have more by the nod part; I think I meant to have him give the officer command of the bridge, then nod as the officer acknowledges, as an affirmation of what the officer was to do.

I'm not quite sure what you meant by Keeneye questioning orders. The only thing he did was ask if the station was safe. At this point the other Troodons don't know anything about where they are, so it's not questioning an order, rather seeking more information on the situation.

I get what you're saying about Darkclaw's mode of command, but at this point most of what he does is relay information from the High Lord. Also the lack of emotion might lead him to not sound like a typical military officer.

If you catch any obvious spelling errors, feel free to mention them, but I'm not going to dwell too much on errors here and there. Typos are to be expected at this point.

Thanks for the comments. It's not easy to comment on something without having read the earlier chapters, but you managed to give useful feedback regardless of that. I really appreciate it.

22
Thanks for the feedback. I'm glad they're coming across as not human. One of my main concerns with this story is to make the main characters relatable, but still clearly alien. With my other main character, Darkclaw, it's not too hard right now because he is emotionless, but I'm glad I'm doing something right with Nayasar and Felivas.

I'm playing around with exactly what to do with the driving part. I think I was trying to avoid using a scene break to skip the whole drive, but I didn't know exactly what to do during the drive. I may try and shorten it, maybe with a scene break for part of it, to give what's left opportunity to up the tension a bit without dragging on for too long.

23
Reading Excuses / Re: June 24 – Hubay, Lord Domestic Ch12
« on: June 24, 2011, 06:09:33 PM »
This chapter was fun where the last chapter was cool. I'll second cjhuitt's sentiments about the officers getting drunk. It's a good way to calm things down after a tense battle. "Do cows have bacon?" is probably one of the funniest lines I've read in a long time.

The Chell also became more interesting when we learn about Jhuz's old teacher. I'm not sure why, maybe because it makes the more accessible, in a way. That they aren't just mysterious powerful creatures. It also humanizes them, which is good because all we've seen so far is them killing people. (unless there was other stuff going on with them in the chapters I haven't read).

I liked the Dombow. I've always enjoyed seeing technology advance in fantasy settings (gunpowder in Wheel of Time comes to mind). I'm not sure what else there is to say about it, other than that I want to see how it affects the world.

24
Reading Excuses / Re: May 30 – Hubay – Lord Domestic Ch 11
« on: June 24, 2011, 06:07:14 PM »
This chapter was really enjoyable. Having missed out on the early battle scenes, I was looking forward to one, and it didn't dissapoint.

There aren't any issues that I had, at least nothing I can remember now. I really loved the scene where Manto got beheaded. It was one of those moments that makes one go 'wait, what?', and pause for a moment before completely realizing what happened. Done right, those moments are great, and it was done right here.

The phrase 'belay that order' didn't bother me at all, though I too have heard it used in various movies and tv shows so many times that it feels completely normal to me.

And thanks for the explanation about why the army has such a high percentage of metsi-I was wondering about that myself.

One final note-I really, really like the Herd. They just seem really awesome. Just putting that out there.  ;D

25
Reading Excuses / Re: May 23 – Hubay – Lord Domestic Ch 10
« on: June 24, 2011, 05:31:31 PM »
And my marathon continues... ;D

I enjoyed this chapter a lot, particularly because of the introduction of Rince. I really like his character. I feel, given the situation that the army is in, that having someone to lighten tension is a very good thing, both for the characters and for the reader.

And I did remember that Ezlio had killed a fox a few chapters back (it helps to have read a bunch in a row), so I understood why Rince killed the porcupine and eagle, and I liked that he did it, because it showed me that while he brings a little lightheartedness to the  story, he is definitely not a 'comic relief character'.

The only minor issues I had were with the war council and Jhuz so easily agreeing to seal the promotion order, but that's been discussed already.

And thanks for posting a general description of the magic, now I think I understand it all, (and I'm pleased at how much I was able to figure out by reading chapters 7-12 before seeing that).

Only one other question. How do people like the squiddies transport their familiars? If their familiar is an underwater creature, do they need to carry around tanks or something? And wouldn't that be a huge liability in battle?

26
Reading Excuses / Re: April 25 – Hubay – Lord Domestic Ch 9
« on: June 24, 2011, 05:31:01 PM »
First off I'd agree with LongTimeUnderdog's sentiments about the rape scene-it's perfectly understandable that such a scene would be difficult/unpleasant to write.

I fee that this chapter did not move the plot forward too much, but I enjoyed it for its descriptions of the airborne forces. That in particular made the army seem more real, in the sense that I can better picture it, having most likely missed descriptions given in the first few chapters.

While it is probably a bit redundant at this point, akoebel's made a good point about emotional impact. Ramping that up would, I think, help add more to the chapter than just the world details.

About the Chell, as of this point in the story I'm viewing them as some sort of supernatural force, which usually is neutral but now for some reason has decided to start killing key people in this army, seeming to imply that something is wrong in the world, either due to something the emperor may have done (as some characters think) or because of some other event.

27
Reading Excuses / Re: April 11 – Hubay – Lord Domestic Ch 8
« on: June 24, 2011, 04:57:27 PM »
As I mentioned in my comments on chapter 7, I am backlogging through what I did not have time to comment on at the time it was sent around, and I'd rather go through these before commenting on the newest chapter.

Again, the earliest chapter I read was chapter 7, so whatever I say comes with not knowing what was explained/happened earlier.


While you called this chapter 'one of the boring bits', this chapter was one of those that really helped me gain my footing in the story. I feel like I have a decent sense of the major characters through this chapter, as well as more information on the army's situation. I as well did not find it boring.

I particularly liked the introduction of Ela (as an important player)-I'd assume she was mentioned at some point earlier in the story. That discussion, as well as his discussion about what to do with the unsigned promotion paper, are quickly giving me insight into Jhuz as a character.

And the interaction between him, Ezlio and Zaisha was great to read. I like them already.

28
Reading Excuses / Re: March 21 – Hubay – Lord Domestic Ch 7
« on: June 24, 2011, 04:56:56 PM »
Seeing as I have the time now, I've decided to try and get through the backlog of chapters I didn't have time to comment on during the school year. One thing to bear in mind-the first chapter I have read of this was chapter 7, so there are bound to be things I don't understand, so feel free to ignore anything that I would know had I read the early chapters.

I'll try not to repeat anything said already, as those comments are months old now.

Despite not having read the early chapters, I think I understand what is going on, at least in general. Through the various events and conversations in the chapter, I was able to glean some information about the magic, which helped both here and in the later chapters.

The only things that bugged me at all were that twice, Jhuz mentions that the army is warming up to him, in almost the same language. The second time I read it, I though 'I know this already, no need to repeat'.

The only other thing was that the prisoner gaze information very easily. I know Jhuz himself remarked on that, and the prisoner explained why she was so, but I feel that her reasoning doesn't make too much sense. Even if she is sure that women where Jhuz is from are incapable of what she does, that sort of information still aids her enemies. It feels more like a way to relay information to the reader than something a prisoner would volunteer freely.

That aside, I enjoyed this chapter a lot, despite the things I don't quite understand yet. I should have comments up for the chapters following this one soon.

29
Hey all, here's chapter 5. In this chapter, Darkclaw and the Troodons arrive at Selixan Station, a station left by the Saviors, created to rapidly build an army for the Troodons.

And and all feedback/comments are useful and greatly appreciated! :)



Summaries of previous chapters:
 
Chapter 1: Executor Darkclaw and his species, the Troodons, awaken from millennia of hibernation. Their leader, the all-powerful High Lord, constructs a vessel for them and they leave their home world, to build an army and conquer any and all ‘inferior’ species.
 
Chapter 2: Introduces Grand Admiral Nayasar, the young supreme commander of the Felinaris military, who is also their heir to the throne. She waits with her subordinate and close friend Admiral Felivas for a formal meeting with her father, in which she will propose a plan to exact revenge on those responsible for an attack on the Felinaris homeworld that killed many. When her plan is not accepted, she storms out and Felivas tries to calm her down.
 
Chapter 3: The Troodons, before building their army, are ordered to raid an information station-essentially a giant library- on the edge of Galactic Alliance space to learn what they can about their eventual enemy. Darkclaw sends his subordinate Praetor Keeneye to lead the mission, and watches through a helmet feed. The station is captured without incident, and Darkclaw completes his mission. He relates this to the High Lord, who instructs him to set a course for a hidden station where they will build an army.
 
Chapter 4: Nayasar is overworking herself, and Felivas demands that she take a mental health day.

30
Reading Excuses / Re: Email List + Submission Dates
« on: June 13, 2011, 11:36:20 PM »
I think I'll just wait until next week. I'd rather not burden everyone with more to read, as everyone seems to be busy.

(And it gives me more time to write chapter 6....)

Pages: 1 [2] 3 4