2532
« on: August 11, 2003, 09:21:32 PM »
Ok, this is a point I will give you. It *is* more of an issue about players than the system. Personally, while I prefer story oriented games, I have nothing against those who prefer "Gamer" or "simulation" styles. If that's the way you enjoy your games, play them that way, and repect for doing it.
The ability to memorise all the rules is certainly beyond me, but I'll take your word that it's possible. It can't be ignored though, that D&D is combat centered/focused. There *is* more of an emphasis on combat than most other things, and so you are in a way forced to adopt a "Gamer" style. It is my opinion, and that is all, that if you prefer combat-oriented games, a wargame is a better choice. I find D&D far to restrictive, mainly in how the class system almost forces you to play a sterotype. But if you enjoy the game, play it.
42, I take offece at the "writer" comment. I could easily retort by saying that it is a *Role-playing* game, and that all people who play d&D are wannabe accountants who get their fun from calculating logistics, but the simple fatc of the matter is that that isn't true, and neither is your comment. I do spend time actually writing, yet I still find enjoyment in crafting a well-tuned story with others in the form of RPGs, such as an Ars Magica saga I am currently involved in. But hey, that's my style.