Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - GreenMonsta

Pages: 1 ... 74 75 [76] 77 78
1126
i think you captured the idea of a kolos very well. i agree that the proportions should intentionallt be altered than those of a human. texture would be nice for accuracy but it isnt neccessary in this case. the only thing that i would maybe attempt would be more detail on the face. in the book these streaches and rips were very prominent on the face making it look less human. but if you were going for a young kolos i think you did a great job and i look forward to more work

1127
Brandon Sanderson / Re: Ruin and Preservation
« on: July 24, 2008, 07:14:56 PM »
the only thing the Lord Ruler needed to keep his throne was not to come up against a person who was Mistborne and also Humerology. the only reason Vin won was because of her special abilities. if she didnt have that combination she would have lost. that revelation was also unintentional. they didnt plan that Vin would have this other ability to help her with the Lord Ruler it just turned out that way. so if the Lord Ruler didnt come up against Vin at that moment more likely than not he would have retained his throne for who knows how long

1128
Brandon Sanderson / Re: The Comprehensive Hemalurgy Thread
« on: July 24, 2008, 07:11:15 PM »
i dont think Ruin would view it that way. he seems to have control over alot of what happens in this world. to maintain his goal he would have to think like a leader and make calculated risks. ok so Marsh gave the goodguys the way to kill the inquisitors, boo hoo. Ruin just made a bunch more inquisitors so that it wouldnt matter if they knew how to kill them they would still have to accomplish it. Ruin had plenty to gain from the situation and how much could he really loose. he could gain limitless info on the person who would release him and their team of supporters. he didnt care about luthandel or the armies or anything, exepct for Vin. all he wanted was for her to make it to the well and that wouldnt have happened with the Lord Ruler in power. so Ruin allowed Marsh to become an inquisitor therfore helping to over throw the Lord Ruler and gaining access to the WoA. after Vin entered the WoA tunnels he turned Marsh and attempted to stop Sazed from getting to Vin. it seems that Ruin used Marsh in the best way available.

1129
Brandon Sanderson / Re: Reen's obsidian
« on: July 24, 2008, 07:03:38 PM »
i have to point out that since the all powerful Ookla made his satement about sometimes pushing people if they were in the right dirrection and sometimes not the topic of conversation had a dramatic fall off. people stopped talking about their insane ideas and started talking about the plain validity of the topic. its it important? this just goes to show the kind of power said people have over us and how much i envy them. besides the point i am often a hypocrite and i enjoy being one. nothing is ever fun unless you can have it both ways.

1130
Ok. . . that was unexpected. Now dont read this and misunderstand. i fully agree that everyone should have their right to choose how they live. weather that includes same sex or anything of the sort. i also think that it takes a long time for a government and a people in general to accept change. i mean look at some of our states currently, there are still some places where rasicm is strong. as a homosexual you can fight for your rights but i wouldnt expect intant gratification. anytime a groupe of people want to change the way things are they are going to encounter resistance. that statement prooves true for any adversity, gay, racial, male/female, any thing. the reality is this topic is to generalized. yes i could see overcoming adversity for greater freedom as being seen as fighting for rights. the only thing is we as readers have the ability to choose for our selves what these instances mean to us. brandon writes about freedom of choice, and if i might add so do many other authors who write fantasy. look at Sword of Truth that whole series is about giving the populace the ability to make the wright decision. so to attempt to pick a topic to compare his writings to would be difficult seeing how you could pick just about any topic and say that his writings could stand for it. ok so im not trying to shoot you down but im just saying this isnt the best place to be discussing such topics, its a place to write about our apriciation of brandons writings and write about topics we as a group of fans might have valid input on due to our collective knowlage about his books. this is not a forum on socially diputed topics. im not telling you to stop expressing your feelings on said topics im just saying find the right place.

1131
Brandon Sanderson / Re: Reen's obsidian
« on: July 24, 2008, 05:14:38 AM »
that more than anything makes me spite alpha readers. dont get me wrong, that would be one of the perks of the job and i would love nothing more than pushing and pulling on all the readers while i knew the answer

1132
Brandon Sanderson / Re: Reen's obsidian
« on: July 24, 2008, 02:15:56 AM »
i agree whole heartedly. the possability of importance instantly creats the opening for countless theories. 

1133
Brandon Sanderson / Re: Reen's obsidian
« on: July 22, 2008, 10:58:39 PM »
now no matter how many times the earring is mentioned it doesnt seem to have any underlying importance besides being a last ditch jumping or shooting anchor, so i dont really follow the idea of a huge importance with the obsidian.

So in your opinion, the countless posts regarding the earring are for naught?
Wait GreenMosta . . . . did you even READ teh books? Not to be rude or anything, but her earring has has been pivotal on many occasions. (I.E. The end of book one!!!!!!!!!!!!)


Ok i can undertand your reasoning and im not faulting it. that was part of my point. yes the earring has served as an important piece to Vin allomanticly but does it have any significane other than being a piece of metal stuck in her. because if your point is that the earring is important due to how she uses it then i agree but that also means that the obsidian could be important because she might use it as a last ditch way to kill someone with allomancy. and im kinda sure i already posted that idea. i think the items can be important situationally but not nesessarily deeply like some are trying to imply. now dont get me wrong im alwase down for a crazy idea or two so im not locked in but i like to point out that like you suggested about the earing being pivitol im sure a metal splinter would have been just as good.

1134
Brandon Sanderson / Re: WOT/Moraine's Letter to Thom
« on: July 22, 2008, 12:24:08 AM »
sick. thats some good research. WOT wiki i guess i am gonna have to check that out for some refreshers on WOT lore.

1135
Brandon Sanderson / Re: Vin as HOA?
« on: July 22, 2008, 12:22:51 AM »
i tend to agree. i think that every factor that has a major part in this story is based off the mist. Ruin, Preservation, Allomancy, Feruchemy. I tend to think that if the mist is destroyed like i think it will be that all of these things will cease to exist. while i think the mist isnt a sentient force in itself it apparently has sentient forces (ruin and preservation) effecting it and living through it. what would happen if the mist was no longer there? would that alone stop the ashmounts or is that something completely differnt

1136
Brandon Sanderson / Re: Reen's obsidian
« on: July 21, 2008, 11:18:42 PM »
i know thats what you were doing i just didnt want it seen in the wrong light. the beauty of opinions is that the are forever alterable. i could read a post that has a great point and on the spot change my idea about the relevance of anything in the books. i just find aruguing subjects like these so entertaining that its hard to pass up questioning something even when i might beleive in it. i think in a past post i expressed that i dont know the items significance but i beleive there to be significance. i only argue both points sometime to play "devils advocate"

1137
Brandon Sanderson / Re: Jordan Fan Here
« on: July 21, 2008, 10:22:38 PM »
having been a jordan fan much longer than a sanderson fan i find it interesting to consider my next statement. after having read brandons books i no longer find myself worried about the outcome of AMoL. i find comfort in the fact that someone as able as brandon has the ability to finish one of his heros timeless stories. i also think that if Wot could get the exposure Tolkien has had then it would deffinately rival it. just because someone creates a language to support a story doesnt make it amazing. jordans world building and character supporting abilities can rival anyone who has written fantasy that ive ever seen. dont get me wrong im a big goodkind/sword of truth fan and i could argue all day but i think jordan was one of the best that we will have the pleasure of reading in our lifetimes. and i now have confidence that brandon will one day reach the same level. maybe not in the way of 12 book epic fantasy but in what ever way he decides to write.

1138
Brandon Sanderson / Re: Reen's obsidian
« on: July 21, 2008, 10:12:18 PM »
please dont take it the wrong way. i dont think posting opinions and ideas about certain aspects of the books are ever for naught. i only beleive that i should express my own opinion while at the same time attemping to stay unbiased. its not that i believe either the earring or the obsidian have no relevance, its more that i can argue either way. i think that both items have the potential to be important but having the potential to be important doesnt make the items important. leaving these items so odscure allows countless ideas to form about their relevance, leaving us (the reader) open to interpritation until something concrete is actually founded. this is an aspect in branons writing i really enjoy. had he for instance talked about the obsidian or whatever is carved on it as much as the earring people would almost instantly see an underlying importance but because he doesnt it makes us feel like there sould be an importance that is only being hinted at.

1139
Brandon Sanderson / Re: Reen's obsidian
« on: July 21, 2008, 08:59:49 PM »
some times its fummy how thread topics can alter during the time of a thread. How things like the significance of "Reens Obsidian" can turn into a well informed conversation on variouse obsidian facts. not that it bothers me, i acctually find most of those inpromptu tidbits interesting. The reality is the obsidian was mention along with the earring as items from Vins past. Both of which once belonged to a past family member. now no matter how many times the earring is mentioned it doesnt seem to have any underlying importance besides being a last ditch jumping or shooting anchor, so i dont really follow the idea of a huge importance with the obsidian. i understant the thought that it might mean something but i would dought it has any real significane in the story line except maybe reminding Vin of Reen at some important time. also glass has the ability to be formed into a fairly soild item that has the capability to withstand slicing and stabbing just as long as the bones are avoides during either motion the glass dagger could be fairly effective.

1140
Brandon Sanderson / Re: Vin as HOA?
« on: July 19, 2008, 06:15:15 PM »
I agree he would more likely have made the prophecy so it would lead the person who enters the WoA to release the power. that is one of the reasons i dont think ruin made the prophecy. i was making the point that it was possible but i think your right that ruin didnt create it

Pages: 1 ... 74 75 [76] 77 78