I loved it. If they do another I will be torn for a couple of reasons. I liked that this showed the fidelity and love of two people in the end, and I am not sure that they have enough for a fourth installment. I would hate to be left with a bad taste in my mouth by a movie that isn't neccassary for completion of the story, when this one did so well, in my opinion.
I think that Calypso was a bit shorted, but I think that the maelstrom was the best you were going to get out of that line after she found out that Davey Jones was the one who had betrayed her in the beginning. I really love Stellan in this role. I thought he was so good.
Johnny Depp, hmmm, what a dish.
I have had a crush on him since 21 Jump Street and it doesn't hurt that he can act very well too, in my opinion. What a joy to watch the play between him, Orlando, and Keira. I think that trio there is the reason the story didn't fall flat on its face from the beginning. I think it could have been so much worse, and I am so glad it isn't.
And Keith Richards of the Stones....am I the only one who noticed him? Now you know why Jack Sparrow is the way he is.
I thought that was a brilliant piece of casting there.
Over all, I thought it tied up the story very well, and gave a sense of closure and finality to it all.