301
Reading Excuses / Re: Nov 2 - Andrew the Great - (As of Yet) Untitled, Chapter 1
« on: November 04, 2009, 02:30:50 AM »
I found the piece . . . lacking in body, for lack of a better phrasing. It had all the skeleton parts, was an obvious middle ages setting with wizards. I hate wizards. Unless there is something in the wizards that matters like ancestry, the idea of the them existing is inherently flawed. It would be like when guns were invented, eventually everyone jumped on that band wagon. There would be no armies, only wizards flying around throwing magic instead of knights on horses bashing swords. Even if it took 30 years to learn the magic, you can bet the military would have every soldier hitting the books instead of the gym. Now that I got that out of the way . ..
There was a bit of wit in the dialogue/monologues that made he piece really enjoyable. I would recommend tightening those up and sewing in a few more and you'll really have us rolling.
I liked the main character, finding his light-hearted antics more then amusing. I do agree with the other, though, that there is little outside his wit that denotes likability. also his motivations were quite unclear. Whiel I know as the reader that a dude with magic is not going to just sack some wagons for kicks and giggles, he still reads like a vandal.
The "Mysterious Stranger," perplexes me. He's not particularly interesting and while he says "I'll kill you," and our roguish hero believes him, I never feel any desperation or concern for the situation. The same goes for the recruitment team. And why is it so bad to be a royal magic dude, anyway? Are the benefits that lousy?
There was a bit of wit in the dialogue/monologues that made he piece really enjoyable. I would recommend tightening those up and sewing in a few more and you'll really have us rolling.
I liked the main character, finding his light-hearted antics more then amusing. I do agree with the other, though, that there is little outside his wit that denotes likability. also his motivations were quite unclear. Whiel I know as the reader that a dude with magic is not going to just sack some wagons for kicks and giggles, he still reads like a vandal.
The "Mysterious Stranger," perplexes me. He's not particularly interesting and while he says "I'll kill you," and our roguish hero believes him, I never feel any desperation or concern for the situation. The same goes for the recruitment team. And why is it so bad to be a royal magic dude, anyway? Are the benefits that lousy?