61
Writing Group / Re: Plea for Help
« on: May 17, 2007, 08:47:47 PM »
I'd suggest increasing the pacing at the beginning. For example, have the character wake up because he's coughing, then open his eyes causing them to sting of smoke, and then have him dive to the floor. It didn't seem to urgent when he woke up, like he was waking up on any other day. It took me a couple of sentences to realize that it was fire. At first I thought it was a hot day and the AC didn't work, or something. Then I was confused by the brown cloud of smoke. Knowing it was YA, I thought the cloud of smoke was mystical (esp. with the description of it diving into his lungs). I reoriented myself, but it took a few sentences.
I didn't have the same problem with gender--I assumed it was a guy--but I don't think there was anything that necessarily pointed either way.
I didn't really get the age of the character until they mentioned high school. I couldn't tell by the way he was acting or how he spoke. Don't know if that's a major problem, but before his parents showed up, I wasn't sure if he was in his 20s or something.
There are definitely some intriguing stuff about him not getting burned, but yet he was burned as a kid, so it's possible. That kind of pulls you in. I'm also wondering how he drowned and got burned at the same time.
The dialog didn't really feel realistic. How deep have you developed your characters? The dialog didn't feel distinctive from one character to another. If you've developed your characters in your mind, it's easier to imagine how they would talk.
There didn't seem like a lot of connection going on between the characters--as if they just met rather than being a family.
In a way, it seems like they don't really want to go back to Slovakia (despite saying they've been thinking about it), and are really worried about moving back there. It creates some intrigue as to why (and why the mom lied about talking about her mother), but at the same time seems weird.
Also, why does Tomas not have anything to stay for? If he's lived there since 6 years old, you'd think he'd have some friends there, despite his burns. I'm surprised he's so willing to move.
I didn't have the same problem with gender--I assumed it was a guy--but I don't think there was anything that necessarily pointed either way.
I didn't really get the age of the character until they mentioned high school. I couldn't tell by the way he was acting or how he spoke. Don't know if that's a major problem, but before his parents showed up, I wasn't sure if he was in his 20s or something.
There are definitely some intriguing stuff about him not getting burned, but yet he was burned as a kid, so it's possible. That kind of pulls you in. I'm also wondering how he drowned and got burned at the same time.
The dialog didn't really feel realistic. How deep have you developed your characters? The dialog didn't feel distinctive from one character to another. If you've developed your characters in your mind, it's easier to imagine how they would talk.
There didn't seem like a lot of connection going on between the characters--as if they just met rather than being a family.
In a way, it seems like they don't really want to go back to Slovakia (despite saying they've been thinking about it), and are really worried about moving back there. It creates some intrigue as to why (and why the mom lied about talking about her mother), but at the same time seems weird.
Also, why does Tomas not have anything to stay for? If he's lived there since 6 years old, you'd think he'd have some friends there, despite his burns. I'm surprised he's so willing to move.