Icons was a 50/50 set for me, I really didn't think any of the the titans needed to be redone except for Beast Boy nor did Cyborg deserve an Unique that's almost the same as the REV that's still legal. Don't think we needed another Cheetah either or a RA's Unique.
Basically all the figs that were unplayable, ie Scarecrow, or had retired was worth getting a new figure that wasn't just a repeat of Hypertimes. If they were in the last 2 sets they really shouldn't have been made unless there was something wrong with the figure.
Aside from Luthor the only figures I wanted from this set were the Jokers, Scarecrow, Bizzaro and the new Beast Boy and Robin. So maybe I should have just bought them off ebay, but then again we wouldn't be getting all those free card sets if I had done that. Also I happen to really like Terra, man is she an underrated figure, a 60 point tactical nuke since you can use the TT TA to make sure she's on that sweet spot click with PW and 4 damage then you can TK her out into the middle of a group of enemies and use Nova Blast. It's sad to see figures get torn apart by players becasue it's not another U Thor or generic power/build combo that 20 other figures have.
With Collateral Damage I'm quite happy that only 3 figures are going to be repeats and the rest are going to be new. Now if they'd only get rid of Bystanders, at least they're adding back in Generics and hopefully one will be a medic.