So vadia, now you're complaining that random little nobodies can become great warriors? Like, um, Vin?
Your argument, if I may misrepresent it for a moment, seems to be that the Lord of the Rings has too many interesting things going on, and too much character development. Of course that's not what you're saying, but that's certainly how it's coming across: "Talk to more unimportant people! Do more boring things!" Ironically, Tolkien's books are brimming with unimportant people and boring events (like I said before, they spend most of it traveling).
I'm going to go with my original assessment, as restated by dawncawley: these are accurate complaints about certain books in the genre, but not these particular ones. I'm beginning to suspect one of two things: 1, you just hate Tolkien and want to complain about him, and 2, you're basing all of your complaints on the movies, and haven't actually read the books.
I reiterate that I am not defending Tolkien blindly against any and all critique--if you want to complain about him, do it. But complain about something he actually did, and that was actually bad, like his weak female characters and his incredibly slow travelogue and his horrible sense of pacing. When you start complaining about "the humble farmboy who becomes a great warrior and saves the world," well, Tolkien actually did that before it was a cliche, and he did it better than just about anybody else who's followed him.