I liked Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe better, but I am continueing to be impressed with the Narnia movies, I love the books, and the movies are amazing. I loved the part with the witch (tildy is such a great actress!) I loved the kids as well, they have a great dynamic, in the first movie they really came across as sibling, and I think that transferred over as well, they kind of remind me of my family (four kids, two boys to girls, same order) so I really gots some of the conflicts they had.
I also didn't mind the added Susan-Caspian romance, I thought it worked ok, and I like how it was mainly just hinted at, and not brought to the forefront, cuz Narnia's not like that.
I also liked how this one focuses on the flaws of the other children, Edmund went thorugh all that in the first movie, and it shows that everyone has thier inner demons.
I thought Prince Caspian was great, can;t wait to see, say, Voyage of the Dawn Treader, if they do a movie of it!