Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - hubay

Pages: 1 ... 11 12 [13] 14
181
Reading Excuses / August 23, Hubay, Fathers of God – Chapter 2
« on: August 23, 2010, 10:57:21 PM »
Alright, alright, I'm a bit late but I did promise I'd get this in. Please please please don't point at laugh at me silk. I don't think I could bear it.

I forgot to put in a content rating on the email, but for this chapter it's (S, V)

Fathers of Gods, Chapter 2 (listener) 3000 words

Recap
In order to discover his god-power, or shri, Cumo was forced sleep with his best friend's lover, Aela. Aela manifested as a flamedaughter, and can control fire, while Cumo can instantly heal wounds – or at least, he can heal burns and minor flesh wounds.

Summary
This chapter is told half by Simeon Listener, a machiavellian Polaesi who can hear thoughts, and half from Cumo again. Some introduction of other gods, more exploration of Cumo's shri, and a hint at life within Shipolitae.

As per a suggestion by Flo (It was flo, right?) I ditched the metal skirt. Cumo and Aela are both wearing ceremonial robes now. They were stashed in the metal box so they never got burnt.

182
Books / Re: What are you reading, part 3
« on: August 20, 2010, 11:25:29 PM »
One of my friends has a complete collection of the wild cards series, to date – they're ridiculously hard to find anywhere near where I live – and in exchange for letting me read them I've converted him into a fan of Shadows of the Apt, Locke Lamora, and Temaire. Makes me feel all warm and fuzzy and superior.

I've also been playing tag with bookdepository.com. I told them to notify me the next time they have Mr. Monster in stock at least five times, but by the time I see their notification email, the copy's already sold.

183
Reading Excuses / Re: Email List + Submission Dates
« on: August 19, 2010, 10:58:27 PM »
I don't have chapter 2 completely finished, but maybe if I tell you guys it will be up on Monday I'll be forced to finish up by then.

Chapter 2 to will be up on Monday.

184
Brandon Sanderson / Re: Mistborn as a Video Game
« on: August 15, 2010, 12:55:10 AM »
What was that game that showed character hands and feet from first person and the acrobatic female main character? Is would remember, but I never played it. :P I haven't gotten around to Mass Effect or Bioshock yet either, but they're just after the Knights of the Old Republic games on my list, and I just got them. Yeah, I'm a little behind the times.

You're thinking of Mirror's edge. I hadn't thought of it, but comboing it with steel and iron would be fantastic. i wouldn't even need another metal as long as i could jump on people.

185
Alright, thanks for the input. I wrote a lot of the end and middle of the book before I finally decided to try the beginning – mostly because of the sex scene – so I wasn't sure how clear it would turn out. You're absolutely right about the skirt, of course. It makes sense later on– Aela has to wear a sort of chainmail because she's always starting on fire and burning off her clothes, and they have a lot of them lying around for people like her. But you wouldn't have any reason to know that, of course, so it's a complete non sequitor. And bizarre to boot.

The intro was supposed to be italicized, if that makes a difference. I forgot to switch it when I finalized the draft.

Looking at this now – and I know it's still early to know for sure – do you think you could get by fine without the prologue? I would have to transfer over some of the exposition, of course. I'm thinking if it's too extraneous, I'll just convert it into a short story.

186
Reading Excuses / Re: Aug 9 - Daddy Warpig - When Gods War, Part 2
« on: August 10, 2010, 05:03:43 AM »
Ha, told you I'd reply quickly. First things first. You don't have a lot of dialogue for the first half of the chapter/part. I know a lot what's going on doesn't need words, but that doesn't mean you shouldn't put a little talking in here and there for punctuation. You do a pretty good job of describing Karrus's (Karrus' ? I never now how to do 's' ending possesives) actions and fight scenes, but every once and a while you throw in a flowery description in the middle of the action and it throws off the rhythm. I did like that despite Karrus's training as a soldier, his lack of arms makes him a considerably less competent fighter. I also enjoyed the howlers' feeding habits.

On that note, you might want to work a little on your headers. I do like that you divide all your sections up into neat little chunks, but the descriptors could be improved upon. "Things that howl" comes off as awkward, and as a copy-writer/journalist I cringe a little when I see a question mark in a headline. That said, the section heads shouldn't be a priority until way later in the game. Even if a couple sound off now and then, your time's better served on the prose. The fact that you're even bothering says a lot – I'm not even going to try giving my chapters headlines until the book's done.

Going into the first few pages of a story, it's hard to judge on the age level/tone the writer is going for, but I thought I had you pegged – until Karrus dropped a few F bombs. Now, I have no problem with that, and you can probably expect an ample amount of language to pop up in my writing soon, but it seemed to jar with the tone you set in the first few chapters. If stars are falling and armies are dying, I expect there to be swearing long before someone mentions travel plans. And I know you fit in a bit of swearing before that, but I guess I just make a distinction between saying "bugger off" and f***.

We also see our first POV from Akara, and I think it wouldn't hurt to hear it sooner, maybe as they make their way into the city. What are her thoughts on last night? What are her motives, besides following Karrus around? What does he even mean to her? You haven't put in a full description of Karrus yet, unless I missed something, so it would be perfect if we could see how he looks through her eyes. Some of that depends on how many more POV's you plan on using. If it's just the two of them, she should get her own spot sooner. If there will be a lot of viewpoints you can probably get away with putting her off.

You turned  mundane warfare and intrigue intro something more sinister pretty quickly, so I'm excited to see where this goes.

187
Reading Excuses / Re: Aug 2 - Daddy Warpig - When Gods War, Part 1
« on: August 10, 2010, 04:30:15 AM »
Like the people above me, I think you've improved on your last chapter consireably, but don't worry too much about rewriting everything until your story is finished. You might also want to trim down the passive voice, but that's more of a line-edit thing. Valkynphyre also brought up a good point about the transition; you could probably still pull off a little more cinematic imagery about the star/god fall, if you talk about them specifically headed towards the city, then switch to the limited perspective as  Karrus sees feels the affects. But that's just personal preference.

A few extra thoughts:

I'm interested to see how big of a role the gods play in this story. The title would suggest they're pretty important, but your intro makes them sound a bit detached from the mundane world. I like the imagery, but the general idea I get from the opening scene is that the gods, though powerful, kind of just mind their own business and fight their own wars. That humans are affected is just a side affect; the gods only make an impact (pun?) when they die. Not a bad thing by any means, but if your gods do meddle in the affairs of humans, it might make sense to make it a little more apparent from the get-go.

I think everyone else covered it pretty well, but I'll put in that your description of Akara seems a little over the top. I do like that you added 'regal' in her description, and combined with the way you describe her crying as that of a leader you create a good way of hinting that she's someone important – assuming she is, of course. But you use the word 'exquisite' too much, for one thing, and after you spent so much time describing her beauty I'm waiting for a catch. The cynic in me says there has to be something wrong with her, and the writer/critic says there needs to be in order to have depth of character. Even if she is actually that beautiful to behold, it might help to give her a fresh scar or something – I was a bit surprised she wasn't hurt, considering the devastation of the star-fall. You don't need personality problems yet, of course, so long as they pop up eventually.

All in all, it's a good start. And since I waited this long to review the first chapter, you can expect the critique for part two in a few minutes.

188
Chapter 1 of 'Fathers of Gods.' Before the main chapter there's a short introduction – about 600 words – from the character Feeder. I've gotten mixed reviews/advice on his voice so I'm looking forward to hear what you all think.

Father's of Gods, Chapter 1 and Feeder Intro

2650 words.


Overall summary

Every year less than a hundred Polaesi are born, and when they turn eighteen they can bend reality to their will and are worshiped as gods – but when they turn nineteen they die. Now one Polaesi has broken the cycle and can live past his appointed time. While attempting to survive a budding war with a rival religion, he must also fight against jealousy and ambition within his own sect.

Chapter summary.

Cumo, now eighteen, has just a awakened to godhood but hasn't manifested a shri yet. The only sure way to force it out of him is sex or torture, so he's been assigned to sleep with Aela, a girl with a similar problem – who also happens to be his best friend's lover.

I'm hoping to get a chapter out every other week so feel free to digitally slap me into action if I don't.

p.s. lethalfalcon, my email was acting funky the other night, so I'm not sure if you ever got my reply, but the new edits worked fine. Thanks!

189
Reading Excuses / Re: Email List + Submission Dates
« on: August 07, 2010, 12:00:18 AM »
Pencil me in for Monday; I've got chapter one ready to go.

190
Video Games / Re: Golden Sun: Dark Dawn
« on: August 06, 2010, 05:44:19 AM »
Ah wow I had forgotten how good the originals were. I sold my gba a while back, though. Might need to emula – er, buy it back again. I was always sad they left it at two games, looking forward to this now.

191
Movies and TV / Re: Inception (Potential Spoilers)
« on: August 04, 2010, 07:08:41 PM »
Was anyone else reminded of the game psychonauts? Way different, of course, and I loved the movie. I just a got a little wave a deja vu when they started talking about projections and white blood cells.

192
Writing Group / Re: I need bad supernatural YA - really, i do.
« on: August 03, 2010, 11:16:24 PM »
I guess "bad" was the wrong word to use. I guess I'm just thinking of the generic "teen fights evil while dealing with high school" sort of story. So maybe more cheesy than bad? I'll probably just take Ruthie's advice and ask a librarian.

And yes, I can see myself failing spectacularly at this, so I plan on spending a lot time researching books where something similar is pulled off. I haven't decided if I should put in a big reveal at the end, or just slowly let the reader figure things out as the MC becomes more and more crazy. What do you guys think?

193
Writing Group / Re: I need bad supernatural YA - really, i do.
« on: August 02, 2010, 11:48:09 PM »
Ah, sorry, cat stepped on my ethernet cable. Didn't mean to start two threads. If a mod could delete one that would be great.

194
Writing Group / I need bad supernatural YA - really, i do.
« on: August 02, 2010, 11:46:33 PM »
I've had an idea for a short story, about a kid who thinks he's fighting evil in highschool, and believes his classmates are secretly vampires, witches etc.. but is in fact just crazy and murdering everyone in his class. I'll add a disclaimer that this is exactly what
I thought I Am Not a Serial Killer was about when I first heard of it. I'm happy it wasn't, but now that I have the idea I want to write the story myself.

I'm not sure if it's been done before – let me know if it has – but I'm really hoping to nail the voice that those kinds of novels would use; that is, the kind of story my killer imagines himself to be in. Not having read much YA for a while now, and certainly not bad YA, I was wondering if anyone could recommend a story or two that I can model after – and no twilight. That's one voice I'll never want to model.

Thanks!

195
Books / Re: What are you reading, part 3
« on: July 31, 2010, 12:49:08 AM »

Have I mentioned how much I like how I am called on these forums?  I'm either an EBR Overlord (who DOESN"T like being called an Overlord?), or BSG (Battle Star Galactica?  I will take that association any day of the week).  Makes me feel all sort of warm and squishy inside.

You know, Mr. Overlord, you should be worried about your new reviewers. I'm sure stealing them away from them away from the human populace has temporarily made your blog stronger, but since you haven't included them in your hive mind they can rebel and usurp your power once the protoss attack. ( I've been playing lots of starcraft 2 lately.)

In related news, your blog has convinced me to finally start reading the Temaire books. I've been putting it off because my library has every book in the series except the first – what gives? –  so I finally had to cave in and buy it.

In keeping with my current 'standard'/fantasy reading habits, I'm pairing His Majesty's Dragon with Devil in the white city. Not as classic as some of my other choices, but I've been meaning to read it for a while.

And Silk: You really should read it if you get a chance. It's one of the better dystopian (it's kind of cyberpunky, but more accessible than your standard fare) books I've read in a while.

Pages: 1 ... 11 12 [13] 14